Q. Pheevr (q_pheevr) wrote,
Q. Pheevr

Marginal phonetics

Julie Kavner / Marge Simpson

In a post evocatively titled "Mmm? Hhmhmhm? Grmrmmm?", Heidi Harley wonders about the articulatory phonetics of the sound Marge Simpson makes to express some combination of disapproval, annoyance, and frustration. (This is part of Heidi's larger project of designing an introductory linguistics course based entirely on The Simpsons.) At Language Log, Mark Liberman, working from memory, suggests that Marge's annoyed voice (both for this particular interjection and perhaps also more generally) involves a combination of creaky voice and pharyngeal constriction, and points out the pressing need for "a good corpus of annoyed and non-annoyed Marge Simpson vocalizations."

Not having the research budget to invest in a suitable corpus, I turned to FindSounds, searched for "Marge," and got seven results. Six were examples of her trademark annoyed noise; the seventh was more of a skeptical "hmmm," which is subtly different. I picked four that seemed to have relatively little background noise, and made spectrograms of them using Praat:

http://www2.hawaii.edu/~hvan/week08/margegroan.wav http://thefreesimpsons.homestead.com/files/sounds/mmmh.wav
http://students.cec.wustl.edu/~wbk1/Lab11/groan.wav http://webcraft1.com/wavs/gavbit.wav

These don't really tell me a whole lot; I'm used to reading spectrograms of sequences of sounds, but just about everything of interest here is happening simultaneously. There is something interesting that changes near the beginning—I think maybe she starts out in modal voice and switches to creaky voice after the first hundred milliseconds or so, but what with all the frication going on, I find it hard to hear or see the creakiness with any confidence. The pitch definitely drops in that transition, but I'm not sure exactly what else is going on with the vocal folds. I also can't tell exactly where the frication is happening, but since this thing's a nasal, I assume it's either radicopharyngeal [ʕ] or velopharyngeal [ʩ].

Anyway, I'd describe the sound as a possibly creaky-voiced bilabial nasal with a very narrow somethingo-pharyngeal secondary articulation and falling tone. I might be able to figure it out better if I could make the sound reliably myself. Heidi can; she writes:

Heck, I can make that annoyed noise too, distinguishing it from the yummy mmm noise by doing some trick with my pharynx/tongue root/larynx, together with the other normal features associated with bilabial nasals, and I don't have anything at all like Kavner's distinctive vocal apparatus.

But when I try to do it, sometimes it comes out sounding like Marge, but sometimes it sounds more like a wounded muskrat or a sexually frustrated wookiee. I also don't have a readily available corpus of non-annoyed Marge sounds with which to compare the samples above. (Marge Simpson has a rough life, you know; there's a lot for her to be annoyed about.) But perhaps these notes will inspire someone else to improve upon my description.

Update: Mark Liberman has posted a much more informative narrow-band spectrogram, together with his analysis, of which my favourite line is this:

I'd guess that there are several different modes of glottal oscillation going on at once, and the whole system is on the edge of chaos (probably in the technical sense of the word).

  • Rakish

    Recently I’ve been watching an Australian TV series called Rake. The title character, Cleaver Greene (played by Richard Roxburgh), is a…

  • A linguist in the land of logic puzzles

    I recently stumbled across the following story in an old file on my hard drive. Judging by the modification date on the file, I seem to have written…

  • Dutch as a bound variable

    What is either today's least surprising statistic or today's most surprising bound variable can be found at Dutch News.nl: The Netherlands has…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.